Bureaucracy often has a negative connotation - think of endless paperwork, complicated procedures, and a rigid structure. But does it really have a place in leadership? Well, it all depends on the situation. Let's dive into the benefits and drawbacks of bureaucratic leadership and figure out when it's effective and if it's the right style for you.
What is the bureaucratic leadership style?
It's a fancy way of saying a system that's all about following the rules to a T. According to the Cambridge Dictionary, bureaucracy is a way to control or manage an organization by employing a large number of officials who make sure that the rules are being followed correctly.
So, what does this mean for leadership? Well, in a bureaucratic leadership style, there's a lot of emphasis on making sure everything runs like a well-oiled machine. This includes things like:
A very clear hierarchy
Everyone knows their roles and responsibilities
Processes are designed to be as efficient as possible
Now, you might be thinking, "Wow, that sounds really strict." And you're not wrong! But that's also kind of the point. When everything is super structured and clear, things tend to run pretty smoothly. Of course, there are some downsides to this approach. For one, it doesn't always leave a lot of room for creativity and innovation.
Is bureaucratic leadership effective?
In certain workplaces, like manufacturing businesses, this style of leadership can help ensure safety, quality, output, and consistency. Everyone knows their role, what to do, and what's expected of them. Plus, it's great for those who thrive on certainty, predictability, and routine.
It's also helpful for customers and suppliers because they can expect predictable results every time. But what about creativity and innovation? Can a company really thrive if it just does the same thing over and over again?
Unfortunately, no. But a smart bureaucratic leader can build in time and space for creativity and innovation. As long as there's a good level of psychological safety, setting aside time to let people's imaginations run wild can be helpful!
One criticism of this approach is the sound of the words hierarchy and chain of command. They can be the downfall of a business if they're not careful. Being slow to change is not a benefit to anyone.
But with the right precautions in place, like a regular review process and investing time and money into innovation, this leadership style doesn't have to hold the organization back.
Is bureaucratic leadership right for me?
Well, it really depends. Bureaucratic leadership shines in rigid and practical working environments, like factories. But can it be applied successfully in other types of organizations?
Let's take an ad agency, for example. A bureaucratic leader might set up processes for everything, from lead generation to billing. Sounds tedious and creativity-stifling, right? But it doesn't have to be. Just like with innovation, you can schedule opportunities for creativity. The point of bureaucratic leadership is to create measures that work. So, if you have a campaign manager who does their best work at home, at 3 am, or around people in unrelated industries, you can allow for that in those measures.
But be prepared to face issues. Clients and their projects won't always fit into your idea of how things should go. Creative people don't always respond well to rigidity. You may also find yourself slower to react to opportunities if you don't streamline your policies and processes.
In reality, this might not be the best way to lead a highly creative team with a varied workload and deep client relationships. But it's not impossible. With some careful consideration and flexibility, you can apply this leadership style in a range of contexts. And if you're still unsure, check out situational leadership for some ideas!
Are you a leader looking for coaching? If so, we have exactly what you are looking for - set up a time for us to chat ASAP - here.
Are you looking for someone to facilitate your next strategic planning session, or for a speaker to motivate your team? We have great solutions. Again, if we can help, please let us know by email or set up a call here.